As my colleague Brandon alluded to in his blog, which you can read here, creativity in content comes with a big asterisk. Search Engine Optimization, commonly shortened to SEO to save a few breaths, asks for clarity and keywords while creative content demands personality to stand out in an ocean of quick reads competing for your attention.
These are not, however, two conflicting ideas. In this blog post, I plan to shed some light on how SEO and content are two sides of the same coin.
Table of Contents
SEO Writes for the Bots, Content Writes for the People
The Title Problem: Clear vs. Clever
Natural Keywords or Keyword Stuffing?
Don’t Cut Your Content Too Short
SEO Writes for the Bots, Content Writes for the People
Search engines and AI answer engines need a way to make sense of the chaos of the internet. They need a well ordered structure, clarity, and context to understand what a page or website is about. People, on the other hand, need a reason to care, trust you, and act. Building a page or a site that satisfies only one of the above fails at its jobs.
Perfectly optimized, but lifeless, copy gets found but it’s ultimately ignored. Beautiful copy that crawlers can’t parse will never be found. There’s a balance and order to the dynamic, not keyword stuffing or large scale automated content creation.
→ SEO is the practice of improving your website’s visibility, relevance, and structure so that it ranks higher through unpaid, or organic, search engine results.
→ Answer Engine Optimization, and if you guessed AEO for this one you’re following along, is the practice of structuring content so that AI can cite you as a source of truth.
The Title Problem: Clear vs. Clever
Getting into the structure, the most important part of any webpage is the title, or, for an SEO expert, the H1 tag. In HTML, the H1 tag is the largest on the page. Best practice dictates that you should only have one H1 tag on a given page, and the explanation below should help make it clear why.
Why The H1 Matters: Your title is important because it tells search engines and users what the page is about, and a good H1 tag should include your primary topic or keyword. If you were running a marketing business, for example, you’d want your H1 tag to include ‘Marketing’.
Why Brands Resist: Brands often see the largest tag on the page as an opportunity to incorporate a slogan, like “Where Ideas Take Flight”, but they don’t offer anything about what the business does. A user might land on the page, look at the slogan, and determine that they’ve landed in the wrong place.
Workarounds: Pairing a slogan with a clear supporting headline or subhead ultimately fuses the two ideas together. Make it descriptive, but provide an answer to the ‘why’ somebody is here. Going back to our marketing example, “Marketing Strategies That Drive Real Growth” both answers a why and makes it catchy (though I’m sure you can do better if you have a brainstorming sesh).
Natural Keywords or Keyword Stuffing?
Keyword stuffing is an outdated practice of cramming a target keyword, or variations of it, into a page far more often than natural writing would. Like an annoying product placement, it reads poorly, erodes the trust of your end user, and search engines have long caught on to the practice.
Returning to our marketing agency example...
An example of keyword stuffing:
Looking for a marketing agency? Our marketing agency is the best marketing agency for digital marketing. Hire a marketing agency that does marketing for your business. Our digital marketing agency offers marketing services, marketing strategy, and marketing solutions.
A more natural way of writing:
We help local companies attract more customers through SEO, paid ads, and email campaigns. Our team builds a strategy around your goals, then tracks the results so you can see what’s working.
In writing content, always aim to use a keyword where it fits, slot in related terms and variations, and write to answer the question the reader is asking rather than trying to satisfy an algorithm.
I’ll address it more below, but Google themselves outline this as their recommended best practice.
Don’t Cut Your Content Too Short
Many teams over-apply the “keep it skimmable” rule.
Thin content provides little for search engines to evaluate and even less for AI engines to cite. Content depth signals expertise and covers related questions your users may have, which builds trust.
Sticking with the theme of this post, there’s a healthy balance that resolves the conflict:
-
Keeping a homepage tight, but skimmable, makes it easy for a user to address if your product or service is the solution to their needs.
-
Giving breadth to your interior pages, service pages, and blogs will build confidence that there’s expertise behind the scenes.
-
Using headers, lists, and short paragraphs breaks up content and keeps the deeper content scannable.
E-E-A-T
Tying all of this together, Google created their own Search Quality Guidelines to judge how well search results meet their quality standards. These guidelines are part of the reason why content still has flair on the internet beyond what the algorithm requires, given that Google holds a chokehold on your browsing experience at 90% of the global search.
Before 2022, the acronym was E-A-T, but they amended an additional E to the front which, when combined, are the building blocks for why content is and always will be human oriented.
While each section of this blog is an individual thought, they each tie in to the E-E-A-T guidelines which, when put into practice together, makes your website and by extension the internet a better, more human experience.
Experience: First-hand stories, real project examples, original photos. Something that can’t be faked with stock photos or generic filler.
Expertise: Depth and accuracy. The argument for depth in content over thin content pieces comes into play here.
Authoratativeness: Author bios, credentials, citations, being referenced by outside sources other than your own.
Trustworthiness: Making accurate claims, having clear contact info, making sure your site is secure, providing honest copy ties back into the keyword stuffing conversation from above.
These guidelines are, of course, one of many in the toolset used to determine how you rank amongst your competitors. Google has, in many cases, made the claim that Trust is the most important of the 4, which is why it’s important to tailor your content towards answering questions over stuffing for content.
Get Found and Get Remembered
If your website is beautifully written but hard to find, or ranks well but can’t hold anyone’s attention, you don’t have to choose which problem to fix. At Vendilli, our team blends technical SEO with content that sounds like a person wrote it (because one did). We’ll look at how your site is structured, how your pages read and where the gaps are between what you offer and what your customers are searching for.
Let’s talk about how we can help your site get found and get remembered. We’ll leave the keyword stuffing to someone else.